If a young person gets in trouble with the police

Last updated: 19 February 2018

Children and young people are treated differently from adults if they get in trouble with the police. What happens depends on their age and how serious the crime is.

Age of criminal responsibility

The age of criminal responsibility in Scotland is 8 years old. This means a child aged 8 or older can be arrested or charged with a crime.

The age of criminal prosecution is 12 years old. This means if a child aged between 8 and 11 breaks the law, their case can't be heard in a criminal court. Instead their behaviour can be addressed by a Children's Hearing.

Children aged 12 to 16 can be taken to court but only for serious crimes. Most offences committed by children of this age will be dealt with by early intervention (like a warning or help from a support organisation) or the children's hearings system.

What the police can do

The police can stop and search young people they think have committed a crime.

If you're 8 or older the police can arrest you, take you to a police station and ask you questions about what happened.

Young people have extra rights if they're arrested. For example, the police must try to contact your parent or guardian if you're under 16.

If the police charge you with an offence they'll normally then release you. However, they may keep you in custody if you're 12 or over and you have been charged with a very serious crime.

If the police keep you in custody this must be at a 'place of safety' such as a children's home or secure care. They should only keep you at the police station if there are no other options, for example if they think you'll be a danger to yourself or others.

The police can only keep you in custody at a station if a senior police officer agrees.

What happens next depends on your age and how serious the crime is:

  • if you're under 16 (or have a compulsory supervision order) a Children's Reporter can decide whether to send your case to a Children's Hearing

  • if you're under 16 (or have a compulsory supervision order) a Children's Reporter can discuss the case with the procurator fiscal, to decide whether to send your case to a Children's Hearing or a criminal court

  • if you're 12 or over and have been charged with a very serious crime the procurator fiscal can decide whether to send your case to a criminal court

  • if you're 16 or 17 (and don't have a compulsory supervision order) the procurator fiscal can decide whether to send your case to a criminal court

The procurator fiscal is the lawyer who presents the case against you at court. They're also known as prosecutors.

If the police can't charge a young person (for example, because they haven't been able to contact them) they can still refer them to a Children's Reporter to decide what should happen.

If the crime isn't serious

If you've been charged with a minor crime the police can decide to:

  • send you and your parents a warning letter
  • get you help for a problem – for example, for drugs or alcohol
  • give you a restorative police warning – a police officer will help you understand the effect of the crime and take responsibility
  • give you a recorded police warning – if you're 16 or over and not on a compulsory supervision order

Police warnings or help from a support organisation won't become part of your criminal record. Information about the crime could be included on an enhanced disclosure or a Protecting Vulnerable Groups (PVG) scheme record as 'other relevant information' by the police.

Instead of going to court

If you're 16 or 17 and the police refer your case to the procurator fiscal, they can decide to give you a direct measure (like a fine or warning) if the crime isn't serious.

The procurator fiscal can also put you on a 'diversion from prosecution' scheme. You'll get help from a social worker or another organisation (for example, mental health support).

Direct measures don't count as convictions but you must admit to the crime. Information about the direct measure could be included on an enhanced disclosure or a Protecting Vulnerable Groups (PVG) scheme record as 'other relevant information' by the police.

If you don't agree to the direct measure, the procurator fiscal can send your case to a criminal court.

Children's Hearings

A Children's Hearing is a meeting where a panel of trained people will listen to the problems you're having and decide what could help you.

This could be a compulsory supervision order, a legal order that could say:

  • where you should live
  • who you should live with or see
  • whether anyone should not be told about your situation

Children under 8 can only be referred to a Children's Hearing on 'non-offence grounds'. This means the hearing will be about caring for and protecting the child, and not about the crime they may have committed. This can't become part of a criminal record.

If the child is 8 or older, they could be referred to a Children's Hearing on 'offence grounds'. This can become part of a criminal record.

If your case goes to court

A court support worker or social worker will help you at court, tell you what to expect and answer any questions you have.

If you're under 18 you can use 'special measures' when giving evidence, such as a live TV link or having a supporter to sit next to you.

The court will be closed to the public if you're under 16 (or under 18 with a compulsory supervision order).

The police and the courts try to keep young people out of custody when possible, for example:

  • releasing them on a police undertaking or on bail until a trial or sentencing hearing
  • giving a community sentence (like Community Payback Orders or tagging) instead of sentencing them to custody

Find out more about what happens if your case goes to court.

Remand and custody

If you are held on remand until a court date or sentenced to custody you may go to:

  • secure care (if you're under 18)
  • a young offenders institution (if you're aged between 16 and 21)

A child under 12 can't be held on remand or sentenced to custody.

Help and advice

You can get advice from a solicitor if you need legal help after getting in trouble with the police. This is free at a police station.

Generally, if you're 12 or older, you can choose your own legal representation as long as you understand what you're doing.

If you need help with your legal costs you might be able to get:

Support organisations

There are also support organisations who can give you free information and advice, including:

Citizens Advice can provide information on young people's rights and legal aid.

The journey through justice guide gives children and young people information about what happens after you're charged by the police.